Game of the Year is something that can and only will be determined by you. No matter what this list says in the end you have your favorites and so does the staff of The Xbox Domain. Collating the picks by the staff and adding up occurrences of each title from every personal list to determine the order of the Top Ten Games of 2009 for the Xbox 360, webring you our result. You may agree and more likely you will disagree. Feel free to argue it out.

Left 4 Dead 2
Valve Left 4 Dead 2Left 4 Dead 2Left 4 Dead 2

Prototype
Prototype

Left 4 Dead 2
Valve Left 4 Dead 2Left 4 Dead 2Left 4 Dead 2

Prototype
Prototype